The True Cost of Big-Box Store Sheds
Finding a cheap shed may seem like a great way to save money upfront…until you discover the hidden costs that can come with a big-box store structure. Costs that are often overlooked include site preparation, practical upgrades, maintenance, and replacement materials over the life of the shed. Big-box store sheds can feature lighter-duty construction, require more maintenance, and be difficult to assemble. Follow along to see the real costs of purchasing these sheds instead of a high-quality, Amish-built structure.
Sticker Price Vs. The Real Price
Comparing sheds based on price alone can lead to additional costs down the road, especially when differences in construction, installation, and site preparation are not considered. When you buy a shed from a big-box store, most times site preparation isn’t considered, leaving your shed at risk of settling unevenly. An improperly prepared site can cause the shed to settle unevenly, potentially leading to premature wear, misaligned doors, or other problems. Big-box store sheds also need to be assembled, which can introduce more costs if you do not have all the tools required, or if pieces are not lined up due to design imperfections. Once your shed is assembled, you may want more storage areas, like shelves, hooks, hangers, etc. If the shed’s wall and roof construction can support these additions, the accessories become another expense to consider.
Some of the most overlooked costs associated with big-box store sheds are maintenance and repairs. Normal wear and tear is expected with any shed and is most times excluded from warranties, but what about issues with the roof or siding? Big-box store shed warranty coverage varies by manufacturer and may include exclusions related to improper assembly, an unlevel foundation, or other installation issues. When buying from a dedicated shed builder, be sure to compare the warranty coverage along with the construction and price. Stoltzfus Structures backs its sheds with a limited warranty.
What are Big-Box Store Sheds Actually Made of?
Most big-box store sheds are made from three different materials: wood, plastic, or metal. These sheds rely on lightweight components, thin metal, or molded plastic panels to keep the costs down. These structures may work well for basic storage, but they may not offer the same structural feel, customization, or durability as a traditional shed. The flooring system can work for small push mowers and basic storage, but some may not be able to handle a riding mower or zero-turn, based on their large footprint and weight. If you do plan to store a riding mower inside, check the door width and height to provide enough clearance and ramp stability. Because plastic and metal sheds are often lighter than traditional wood structures, proper anchoring can be especially important so high winds don’t damage your structure. Don’t overlook the small aspects, like hardware. Hinges, latches, fasteners, and handles can experience considerable wear over years of use. Some lower-priced shed kits use lighter-duty hardware to help keep costs down, which may be more susceptible to loosening, bending, or corrosion over time. Unlike big-box store sheds, Stoltzfus Structures sheds are Amish-built and use high-quality materials. Check out a test we did on a big-box store shed vs. our traditionally built sheds HERE.
Foundation Problems
Even a high-quality shed can develop foundation problems, which is why site preparation is required before Stoltzfus Structures delivers a shed. With many big-box store sheds, the customer is responsible for preparing the foundation. If the shed is built directly on the grass or uneven blocks or gravel, the shed could settle unevenly, the doors may not open properly, and water could pool under and around the shed. Poor drainage can also lead to moisture problems, rot, and premature deterioration of certain materials. An uneven foundation can even cause the floor to sag since it doesn’t have the necessary support, and it will cost extra money to repair or re-level the foundation. A lower upfront price may sound appealing, but unexpected repairs, site preparation, and additional storage upgrades can increase the total cost of ownership. A higher-quality shed may cost more upfront but can provide greater long-term value through durable construction, professional site preparation, customization, and warranty coverage. Stoltzfus Structures can give recommendations for site prep, or you can get your site prep done with us.
How Stoltzfus Structures Builds
Stoltzfus Structures builds traditionally framed wood structures using premium materials designed for lasting performance. You can see all of our shed specifications HERE, but at a glance, depending on the model, construction may include pressure-treated foundation skids, dimensional-lumber floor joists and wall studs, wood flooring, a fully sheathed roof, and a variety of roofing and exterior material options. Customers can also choose from numerous colors, doors, windows, and other custom features. Because of this construction, our Amish-built sheds may cost more upfront than many big-box store options, but also allow more customization, site preparation options, and warranties. For our sheds, you can expect a 10-year limited warranty and access to our shed specialists if questions or concerns arise before, during, or after delivery. You can see more about our warranty by clicking below.
Stoltzfus Structures offers several shed categories, including Storage, Dormer, Garden, and Elite sheds. Storage sheds are our most straightforward and cost-effective, often storing lawn equipment, tools, seasonal items, or general storage overflow. Dormer sheds are a variation of our storage sheds but with added architectural design, like the upgraded roof lines and dormers. Garden sheds combine practical storage with more decorative details and are common for storing garden tools. Some garden shed models come with a porch to add more character and style to your backyard. Elite sheds offer a more premium appearance and can be customized for storage or transformed into hobby spaces, playhouses, backyard retreats, and more.
Thinking of choosing a traditional, Amish-built shed instead of a big-box store structure? Contact us or call our team at 610-593-7700 to customize your shed to best fit your storage needs, style, and property.
Jada Morris
Recently graduated from college, I take advantage of having more free time and spend those moments catching up on my love of reading, brainstorming ideas for design projects, and spending time with my family, friends, and furry companions. I have two Golden Retrievers that are complete opposites, one who has enough energy to run three marathons a day if he could, and the other who would be happy to stay in bed all day! I might relate a bit more to the later but am always up for an adventure.
